CAVEAT >>> This is regarding my car and I am not a mechanic... the following statements are argumentative... research and decide...
I got rid of the EGR... no issues. The exhaust temp will likely be higher (probably about 100 degrees according to tests done).
Did I do it because I thought it improved the engine? Nope. Did it because its unmonitored on a MK3 (North American) except in California. Mine was leaking for a few years and I had no idea it was doing so. Also, the parts that I wanted to replace were no longer available OEM. So... it is gone.
Am I going to have issues? nope. Is it going to hurt the environment? nope. Neither is removing my cats.. although it smells funny.. lol.
Its all in keeping things in perspective. A proper block-off will work just fine. If it was a critical part of the engine it would/should be monitored.
As for no cats & no EGR, I personally only drive about 3000-5000 km per year (that's ALL vehicles) so.. why would I worry? Other things to think about.
Bottom line.. you can delete the EGR and your engine will be fine (just do it properly). Just be aware your EGT's will be slightly higher.