PDA

View Full Version : Oil Analysis - Post your VOA and UOA Here



Supracentral
04-05-2007, 04:28 PM
Jdub,

I decided to change the oil early on my MKIV. Something just didn't feel "right" about the way she was running. After the change she seemed to smooth out again, but I know how the placebo effect works with this stuff...

I sent the oil out for testing. Here's what they came back with:

http://www.supracentral.com/private/oil-test-christine-04.07.jpg

Have anything to add to that analysis?

jetjock
04-05-2007, 04:55 PM
I'll take a shot at it Mike. I've interpreted a few of these in my time ;)

Not bad for one test but you really need trend to know what's going on. Silicon is high. Normally that might be attributable to sealant or the antifoaming agent used in some oils but with the high Al to go along with it I agree with them. Running an K&N or some other performance filter? Otherwise the oil held up pretty well. Not much shearing, you could've gone much further on it. Fuel dilution looks great too, as does coolant. Is that RP SM rated? The phosphorus seems to indicate it is. I also thought RP had more moly in it but guess not. Maybe it's RedLine I'm thinking of. That said I've never been a fan of RP because of the add pack.

jdub
04-05-2007, 07:17 PM
According to RP's website, the 5W-30 is a SL/GF-3 oil. It does not have a lot of moly in it...Red Line is much higher.

I was going to make the same comment as JJ about the silicon...I do believe RP uses a silicon based anti-foaming agent. But the high Al and slightly high Fe leads me to believe its wear due to dust/dirt getting past the air filter. What kind of air filter are you using? Here's some more info on silicon levels in oil:
http://www.blackstone-labs.com/the_silicon_bugaboo.html

The rest looks great...no fuel or coolant is a big plus! Did you have a TBN done on the sample? TBN will tell a lot about what kind of useful life is left on the oil. Take a look at this:
http://www.blackstone-labs.com/do_i_need_a_tbn_.html

Another suggestion...have a VOA (virgin oil analysis) done on this oil to include TBN. That way you will have a starting point to judge the values.

jdub
04-06-2007, 10:37 AM
Whoa...I never knew you could send your used motor oil for diagnostic testing. Thats way too hardcore for me. Still very neat!


Tells you an awful lot about what's going on in your motor. On the $$$ side, it also tells you when your oil really needs to be changed vs. the 3,000 mile OCI that is pushed by the various shops. A true syn oil (like RP) can go 8,000 miles easy without doing analysis...if you do like SC does, you can go 12,000 to 15,000 miles based on what is happening in your motor.

Consider this: If you use high quality oil and filter and change every 3000 miles, it will cost you $40 each time...that's $120 over a 12,000 mile period. Blackstone analysis costs $34 (including TBN & postage) and you do it every 4000 miles...that's $102 over the same mileage interval. Plus (a very big plus), you can tell if the oil you are using is suited to your motor based on wear metals and how the oil holds up in terms of additive pack/viscosity. And you don't contribute to the profit margin of the major oil companies ;)

The Blackstone kit is free:
http://www.blackstone-labs.com/free_test_kit.html

Standard analysis cost $22.50 and TBN (highly recommended) is an additional $10....postage for the sample via USPS costs $1.59 You want to take the sample after draining a small amount of oil or take it directly from the dipstick tube. Here's the procedure:
http://www.blackstone-labs.com/gas_sampling.html

You want to send in a virgin sample 1st (VOA) to get the baseline for the oil you are using. Then send in a used sample (UOA) for analysis. Like JJ said, one sample is not going to ID a trend...it will take several samples to see if a certain oil is what you want to use.

This little gizmo makes it easy to take samples:
http://www.supramania.com/forums/showthread.php?t=38929

Fozbo
04-23-2007, 11:20 PM
A database of virgin oil sample analyses would be nice (since theorectically the specific oil brand/weight/additive should remain fairly constant).

mkIIIman089
03-09-2008, 07:31 AM
Would standard "bottom end" bearing material be elevated if a stock CT rapidly went south over the course of an OCI?

I could post my UOA, however I'm afraid there are more things going on and exceed "normal" conditions. I don't think it would be a fair comparison for the oil if someone were to research UOAs.

Supracentral
03-09-2008, 09:39 AM
Would standard "bottom end" bearing material be elevated if a stock CT rapidly went south over the course of an OCI?

It shouldn't be. Stock turbo bearing failure puts brass into the oil if I remember correctly. (Someone correct me if I'm wrong on that... It's been a while...)


I could post my UOA, however I'm afraid there are more things going on and exceed "normal" conditions. I don't think it would be a fair comparison for the oil if someone were to research UOAs.

Post it up, I think you probably have something else going on in the motor. What caused the turbo to fail? That's your real question.

Also what oil? How long is the OCI? Anything else going on with the motor we should know about?

mkIIIman089
03-09-2008, 09:55 AM
http://img235.imageshack.us/img235/8472/d31828mp7.th.gif (http://img235.imageshack.us/my.php?image=d31828mp7.gif)

-The reason for the relatively thin oil and very long OCI were simply because I was curious to see what would happen.

-It would seem that I have a trickle of a BHG or something going on for coolant contamination. It appears to very slowly be getting worse compared to other UOAs. Those, however, were at roughly half this interval.

-What killed the turbo most likely was just abuse from running more boost. I think, at least.

-Makeup oil is from a large oil leak... which to my amazement does not seem to be coming from any shaft seal, o-ring, or valve cover near the oily area. (from just above the water pump - down)

jdub
03-09-2008, 06:35 PM
Your wear metals are high and it looks like it's a direct result of coolant in the oil. Turbo failure *could increase* iron and copper, but the rest indicate bearing wear from damage caused by the coolant. You are getting some fuel dilution as well, indicating blowby on your rings. Both are excellent reasons to change oil more often as Blackstone suggested to keep coolant/fuel levels down in the oil.

I would run a thicker version of RL (5W-30) due to this wear (your bearing clearances are opening up) and change more often like the analysis suggested. You might consider changing to an oil like German Castrol (0W-30) that's thicker at ops temp.

Is your PCV system in good shape?
What filter are you using and how often are you changing it?

Edit: merged threads with the same subject ;)

jdub
03-09-2008, 07:13 PM
I have switched to GC, and plan on resampling in 4k miles.

As you suspected my #3 piston's rings are shot.

It was an Amsoil EaO, each oil change. Now the Mobil 1 that came with the GC sale, and will be changed with the oil.

Fuel dilution - I'm still well below the recommended spec on the analysis, but you say it's high?

Fuel dilution is not that high, but it is a contributing factor...it will thin the oil more than you want at ops temp. With coolant in the oil, it can (and seems to be in this case) cause bearing wear.

Amsoil EaO filters are excellant...probably the best filter out there.

Good plan on the next analysis...you want to do them about every 3-4000 miles. You might want to take one a bit sooner to see what's happening with the coolant issue. Also, get a TBN done if you plan on using extended drain intervals.



My plan from here on out was to start using more easily attainable/less expensive oils. As systematically analyzing them as I could to find which performs best, so TBN was going to be included in my next sample.

I don't doubt that EaO filters are very good (best?), but the price premium you pay for the best is out of my range right now. As is just fixing all of these mechanical issues.

In adddition, you said I should bump up the viscosity some. I did but only because it was the only grade that is highly regarded, if the increased wear was changing bearing clearances enough to need a thicker oil, would I notice a pressure drop?

I'm sure you know your stuff, but after reading AE Haas a while back, I can only question recommended viscosity increases to know the exact reason behind it.

You're dead on about the price on the EaO filters...they are the best, but justifying the cost is hard to swallow. That is the reason I don't use them ;)

With increased bearing clearances due to wear, you may or may not see a pressure drop. Even more so on a 7M turbo due to the way the stock filter head/cooler loop and oil squirters bleed pressure above ~40 psi. Thicker oil at ops temp will help fill that increased clearance and provide *some* protection to the bearings due to increased boundary layer lubrication a thicker oil provides.

Notice I said "ops temp"...GC flows very well cold, but is closer a 40W at 100 deg C. It's an excellent combination for the motors you see in a Supra. These motors (7M, 1J, 2J) are a bit dated when it comes to the tolerances the companies are building to now, that's why you see a 0W-20 spec'ed for the new engines...close bearing clearances and fuel savings. A xxW-30 is more appropriate for our engines...a little thicker if it's showing wear. GC fits this bill nicely ;)

KicknAsphlt
03-10-2008, 02:11 AM
Here's mine...

mkIIIman089
03-10-2008, 03:55 PM
Here's mine...

LOL. Nice timing, looks like I'm not the only one with that slightly leaky HG problem. You seem to have a nearly identical problem.

Edit that last post... how long did you run on that oil? I doubt it was 137,500 miles... ;)

jdub
03-10-2008, 04:34 PM
Yep...the high levels of sodium and potassium indicate coolant. That leads to wear on the bearings and drive the wear metal values up just as the analysis shows. You also have a fairly high level of silicon...bet you're using a K&N air filter ;)

I would dump the 20W-50 for a 30W multigrade.

KicknAsphlt
03-10-2008, 10:23 PM
LOL. Nice timing, looks like I'm not the only one with that slightly leaky HG problem. You seem to have a nearly identical problem.

Edit that last post... how long did you run on that oil? I doubt it was 137,500 miles... ;)

Changed it last March, but the thing uses oil pretty regularly...so it always gets a fresh quart every so often...LOL! My car has a MHG that the previous owner put on, but the car overheated last year on my way back from Vegas...since then, I've had cooling issues with the damn thing, and I've gotta add coolant/water every so often (not drastically, but every probably week and a half or two weeks)...I think I either warped the head, cracked it, or maybe cracked the gasket (if that's possible)....or maybe they didn't finish the gasket surfaces on the head and/or block properly before installing the gasket. I was gonna try a retorque first when I get it back from the body shop. If that doesn't work, then well....time to yank the head off and see what's wrong. Oh, and that's my first analysis for this car.



Yep...the high levels of sodium and potassium indicate coolant. That leads to wear on the bearings and drive the wear metal values up just as the analysis shows. You also have a fairly high level of silicon...bet you're using a K&N air filter ;)

I would dump the 20W-50 for a 30W multigrade.

Roger that, I'll take that under advisement. :icon_bigg

SupaMan
03-24-2008, 02:24 AM
i have a question, im changing my oil soon and im gonna take a sample i already sent my info to blackstone requesting a sample kit.

my question is, how long do you guys wait once you crack the drain bolt/valve open? it says to try and get the middle of the draining oil not the start or the end. i was just curious.

jdub
03-24-2008, 09:03 AM
I let about a quart drain, then fill the bottle. Use Black Stone's bottle and be very careful when you open to fill...don't touch the inside or let anything but oil get in it.

For UOA's between changes, this makes it easy:
http://www.supramania.com/forums/showthread.php?t=38929

Apollonius
03-25-2008, 10:08 AM
Is it worth it to send them a sample after a fresh oil change to get a reference point? or should i wait about 3000 miles?

Oh and that engine oil drain valve is a very nice product thanks for the info jdub

jdub
03-25-2008, 10:21 AM
I'm a believer in a VOA to get a baseline on the oil before it goes in the motor. That way you can see what metals are already in the oil and it's TBN.

adampecush
04-07-2008, 02:03 PM
Here are a couple UOAs from my daily driver. While not supra related, they are rather interesting. Jdub helped me out in figuring out what was going on and indicated that I should post my results as they might benefit others in similar situations.

The car is a 2002 maxima with a VQ35 engine - 6MT with 120,000 km on the clock. I did a UOA on the first oil change (to GC Syntec 0W30) after I bought it. The first analysis indicated high sodium (As well as high molybdenum and boron - not additives in GC 0W30), a sign of coolant contamination. Blackstone indicated that I had coolant in the oil, however, it appears as though this was based upon the ICP spectrometry alone, not a glycol test.

After digging around, I found that the previously used oil was an esso/exxon/mobil conventional oil which reportedly may have used sodium in the additive package. I sampled at the next oil change and re-submitted. The most recent results indicated that sodium, boron, and moly dropped by about one-half; however, the lab again suggested the presence of coolant despite the fact that the oil tested negative for glycol.

This is a case of there being more to the actual condition of the engine than meets the eye. I was seriously considering having the cooling system pressure tested, but as the car never overheated or lost coolant, I decided to do one more UOA before pursuing the potential problem further. As you can see, one UOA does not tell the whole story about the condition of an engine. My advice is that if you choose to analyze your oil, do so on a regular basis. It isn't overly expensive, and it can generally save you money by both allowing to safely extend oil change intervals, and discover problems before they become costly.

UOA 1
http://www.supramania.com/forums/vbpgimage.php?do=full&p=4474
UOA 2
http://www.supramania.com/forums/vbpgimage.php?do=full&p=4475

CyFi6
11-07-2008, 03:32 AM
Here is mine, any other thoughts besides those already presented?

Supracentral
11-07-2008, 07:21 AM
I agree, get a better filter then submit new samples after 3K on new oil with the new air filter.

If the wear comes down, then you can start extending the distance between your oil changes.

jdub
11-07-2008, 08:55 AM
Are you using a K&N air filter? If so, it's crap...get an AEM dryflow if you are going to stick with a cone type filter.

On other thing I noticed is your TBN has dropped to half of what that oil started at (11.3)...while Blackstone is correct concerning the additives and the TBN, a 50% drop over 3000 miles is a lot. TBN is an indicator of the oil's ability to "clean up" acidic combustion byproducts that oxidize oil...detergent additives are used up in the process. It's not the present level that's a concern, it's the rate of detergent consumption your TBN is showing.

Change this oil soon and get a new air filter.



The air filter in there now is just a regular stock looking filter, nothing performance related. It is the same one tat came on the car when i bought it over a year ago. Are the stock replacement filters from pepboys and other auto pars stores sufficient? I don't really want to go away from the stock air box so id like to get something that fits in there.

Ahhh...even better. You want an AC Delco filter...it's the best. A Baldwin air filter would be the next choice, but that may be hard to find. Wix air filters are above average for a 3rd choice.



Assuming contamination brought up my silicon levels, would it also account for my excessive bearing (Pb) and Fe levels? If not, what could have caused this wear?

Personally, I think that's a bad assumption. ;)
Especially with an air filter that's over a year old.

If you have dust/dirt from your intake being sucked into the cylinders, it's like sandpaper. Yes, you will show higher wear metals as a result.

Supracentral
11-08-2008, 02:56 PM
Assuming contamination brought up my silicon levels, would it also account for my excessive bearing (Pb) and Fe levels? If not, what could have caused this wear?


Personally, I think that's a bad assumption. ;)
Especially with an air filter that's over a year old.

If you have dust/dirt from your intake being sucked into the cylinders, it's like sandpaper. Yes, you will show higher wear metals as a result.

The data doesn't add up. If it were just elevated silicon, I'd suspect your sample was contaminated, but those hight Pb and Fe levels coupled with the silicon indicate engine wear due to poor air filtration.

Replace the filter, wait 3,000 miles, test again and report back.

supradjza80
11-13-2008, 04:56 PM
I just had an analysis on my oil done with 4,038 miles on the oil (Castrol Syntec 0W-30 Euro Formula). Couple things I don't like - here is the analysis

Wear metal PPM
Copper 3
Aluminum 3
Iron 10
Silicone 11
Chromium 1
Lead 7
silver 0
Nickel 1
Tin 4
Sodium 41


Viscosity
100 Deg. C in cst 8.8 ?? should be around 12.2 :1zhelp:

Neg Fuel Dilution
Neg Anit Freeze dilution
.05 % water
0% soot

Additive Element PPM
Zinc 1181
Phosphorous 993
Calcium 2234
Magnesium 566
Barium 0

I had Benz Oil in Milwaukee Wisconsin do the testing but think I will be switching to Blackwood since they give you a better comments/recommendation and have a few more things they test for.

jdub
11-13-2008, 09:31 PM
It would help to get specifics on the oil you are using...sorry, but I don't have that memorized for all the people I deal with on that subject here.

The wear metals are at the upper range or a bit high, but overall not that bad. I would suspect the same issue as above...dirt/dust getting past the air filter.

The viscosity is a different story...that is a pretty big amount for the oil to shear down. Oil temps?

supradjza80
11-14-2008, 11:17 AM
oops, forgot I didn't post that. I am using the holy grail of oil, Castrol Syntec 0W-30 Euro Formula. I don't know what the oil temps are but I doubt they are high enough to warrant that kind of oil shear down.

jdub
11-14-2008, 12:40 PM
I assume this is a 7M? I'm curious...what kind of air filter do you have and when was it changed?

I have never seen GC shear that much with that mileage...that is ?W-20 viscosity. Since GC is a PAO oil, it does not have the VII content you see in other oils that can be a cause of this magnitude shear. Heat is the only other explanation since you are not showing any fuel dilution. What cooler circuit do you have?

This assumes the analysis is correct...I'd have it double checked to be sure. If it is accurate, I would change the oil.
BTW - you should always have a TBN done in an oil analysis.

supradjza80
11-14-2008, 03:08 PM
It is 7m with stock oil cooling circuit.

I bought the car in may with 82,000 miles on it and put on a brand new Apex intake with apex filter at that time.

I change the oil right when i bought the car and used 10W-40 GTX. Then after reading what was on this site I decided to change the oil to the GC 0W-30 and did this after 3000 miles.

I did the analysis on the GC when i changed my oil with 4000 miles on it. I knew this was early to change the GC but it was just the easiest way for me to get the sample using the tools I have at college. I did put in fresh GC at this time.

Either way I have serious doubts that the viscosity number is correct, but it is really hard to say. I did fill another sample bottle when I changed the oil so maybe I will see if blackstone can analyze the oil using someone elses bottle kit...

The car only has the intake, and BIC DDP to 2.5 inch straight pipe for mods so I doubt the oil was overly warm even during times that I was driving the car hard. I have also done a compression test on the motor around 89,000 miles and it was 150 across the board.

I always watch the oil pressure gauge I when cruising on the highway (during a long drive lets say) the pressure is always right up around 40. After driving the car hard and taking it up on the highway the pressure is in the same spot when you take it to highway speeds cruising. This is with the stock gauge, but mine seems to be pretty accurate, and if it isn't accurate it at least reads the same under the same conditions day to day.

Also what is a TBN?

jdub
11-14-2008, 03:18 PM
TBN = Total Base Number. This tells you the remaining ability of the oil to neutralize acidic byproducts of combustion. If everything else is good, you use this number to determine when to change the oil.

supradjza80
11-14-2008, 04:16 PM
TBN = Total Base Number. This tells you the remaining ability of the oil to neutralize acidic byproducts of combustion. If everything else is good, you use this number to determine when to change the oil.

ok, yes they did not give me this number. but they do say in their comments section that this oil is good condition and is suitable for continued use...which is funny since the viscosity is 8.8 and its a 30 weight oil (they knew what oil i was using).

Like I said I think i am switching to black stone. And I think since my oil pressure never changed throughout using the oil that the viscosity probably didn't change much either. Even with the new oil the gauge does exactly what it did with the old stuff under the same conditions...

Piratetip
05-01-2009, 05:05 PM
My brothers oil change interval went longer than expected.
I suggested he should have it tested.
It turned out better than I expected, definitely used the whole life of the oil.

Here are the results.
LMK what you guys think.
http://i301.photobucket.com/albums/nn77/ntippet/BlackstonePrius.jpg

jdub
05-01-2009, 06:19 PM
That's damn good for 15K miles...looks like that motor likes Mobil 1 ;)
Illustrates a case in point...most people change their oil way too often.

Does that engine run rich? I'd take steps to reduce the fuel dilution. Use a better air filter (AC Delco for stock air box) and change it per the manual interval...that will help the wear metals.

Piratetip
05-01-2009, 06:49 PM
People DO change their oil too often! :)

Were trying GC this time around at 10k, oil analysis again.
Was on sale and figured why not.

I would say that the engine probably does not run rich (55mpg), the stop start characteristics may have some impact on the fuel getting past the rings.
Will look in to what may be causing the fuel dilution with this 1.5L engine.

Will check to see the last time the air filter(s) were changed, there are 2 in series so I would be surprised to see anything going through them.

Running GC in my DD now and will do an oil analysis at 7,500mi to see how much life is left in it.
I am hoping for 15,000mi, but well see.
Those results will be posted here also.

jdub
05-01-2009, 06:51 PM
Get a TBN as well...that will tell you how much life is left in the oil to neutralize acids.

Piratetip
05-01-2009, 06:58 PM
Oil analysis without TBN would be frightful (and handicapped). :)

jdub
05-01-2009, 07:02 PM
LOL...tis true ;)
The one in the analysis is right at the min I would accept...I have to say (though I dislike Mobil 1 oil), 15K is damn impressive. If the GC doesn't meet expectations, I'd switch back.

Piratetip
05-01-2009, 07:32 PM
Will do.

I suspect the fuel dilution to come down as temperatures here have risen.
The Prius was driven in the winter and it was damn cold here some days.

dumbo
06-28-2009, 11:00 AM
Here is my sample, what do you all think? NA-T done about 2-3 thousand km's ago maybe...Might explain the silcone, that or a leak, or my shitty air filter.

Lead is scaring me. Glad to see no potassium or coolant/water.

The rebuild was done by the PO, and I only took his word so you never no, but its got the signs of one...

jdub
06-28-2009, 11:24 AM
Yep, the lead is a cause for concern..copper and tin are a bit high too. All point at the bearings. Is this the 1st fill after the rebuild?
(i.e. did the PO change the oil right after 100 miles and then again after 500? Or, did he fill and go till you changed it?).

What kind of air filter are you using?

dumbo
06-28-2009, 11:37 AM
Yep, the lead is a cause for concern..copper and tin are a bit high too. All point at the bearings. Is this the 1st fill after the rebuild? (i.e. did the PO change the oil right after 100 miles and then again after 500? Or, did he fill and go till you changed it?).

What kind of air filter are you using?

Im sure he changed it, he told me he was a Nissan tech for 10+years, and he did the head retorque after a few heat cycles. Told me he had the deck/head machined ect.(Wish I knew then what I know now, I'd have A LOT more questions) I've changed it 3-4 times I think myself, the sample was taken on the second oil change since I turbo'ed it IIRC, and the first one after the cam swap. Makes me wonder why the viscosity is low with such little km's on it...maybe the fuel?

Time well tell I guess...If I ever get home to drive it haha..

supradjza80
07-21-2009, 11:56 PM
Here is my most recent analysis, makes me think the first place that ran it (last oil change) did not know what they were doing. I also chuckled a little bit when I saw they put down V6 instead of I6, I know I didnt put that down wrong :)

jdub
07-22-2009, 07:34 AM
Not bad at all Dave...what kind of oil filter? What kind of air filter?
What's really good to see is you have zero coolant & water in your oil and very little fuel dilution...your PCV is working very well.

As you can see, that oil had tons of life left. GC will go 8K easy with at filter change at 4K.

dumbo
07-22-2009, 08:35 AM
What are the Universal averages? My sample doesn't look a whole lot worse than supradjza80 and there telling my it is, I don't understand.

How come our universal averages are different on the same engine?

supradjza80
07-22-2009, 09:49 AM
Not bad at all Dave...what kind of oil filter? What kind of air filter?
What's really good to see is you have zero coolant & water in your oil and very little fuel dilution...your PCV is working very well.

As you can see, that oil had tons of life left. GC will go 8K easy with at filter change at 4K.

K&N Filter - I get them free with the oil when AutoZone has the oil change specials - Are there any filters that you think can make the full 8k miles without a change? Or would you recomend just changing it anyway to be safe, I wouldn't want to go into filter bypass.

Apex Air Filter

I will be trying the longer change interval and see what happens from there.

supradjza80
07-22-2009, 09:52 AM
What are the Universal averages? My sample doesn't look a whole lot worse than supradjza80 and there telling my it is, I don't understand.

How come our universal averages are different on the same engine?

Dumbo - The only reason I beleive they are concerned with your values is due to the amounts found in the oil after just 1000 km or 620 miles (maybe this was entered wrong on the oil analysis sheet?). As you said my values are similar but on a motor with 95000 miles on it and 4300 miles on the oil.

dumbo
07-22-2009, 01:18 PM
Dumbo - The only reason I beleive they are concerned with your values is due to the amounts found in the oil after just 1000 km or 620 miles (maybe this was entered wrong on the oil analysis sheet?). As you said my values are similar but on a motor with 95000 miles on it and 4300 miles on the oil.

Ahhh, yes I missed that part haha.

jdub
07-22-2009, 04:51 PM
jza80 - The Amsoil EaO filter can easily. Probably the best at filtration as well...hold on to your wallet ;)
With a longer OIC, there's a very good chance your wear metals will actually drop.

Dumbo - Plus, your silicon level was over 3 times what jza80 had...that points straight at a filter issue. Combined with the wear metals you were showing during such a short time was not good. Concerning the universal averages, take a look at his:
Understanding the Oil Report (http://www.blackstone-labs.com/eng_balloon_report_.html)

This link explains the trace elements. Keep something else in mind, the element numbers are in parts per million...think about that for a minute.
Understanding the Elements (http://www.blackstone-labs.com/gasoline_diesel_report_expl.html)

If the engine is not correctly identified to Blackstone, the averages are not going to do you much good. I'm pretty sure this is why the universal averages are different for the 2 reports...jza80's motor was ID'ed as a V6.

supradjza80
07-23-2009, 01:08 AM
If the engine is not correctly identified to Blackstone, the averages are not going to do you much good. I'm pretty sure this is why the universal averages are different for the 2 reports...jza80's motor was ID'ed as a V6.

Thanks Dub, i just emailed them to see if I can get the report fixed and have them change the unit information in their system.

Also is the Amsoil filter the only one you would be comfortable running more than 4k miles or are there others?

jdub
07-23-2009, 08:38 AM
Donaldson makes a filter that is comparable, but I do not know of a reliable source...pretty sure Donaldson makes the EaO for Amsoil. The CM is an alternative, but has a pretty steep initial cost:
http://www.cmfilters.com/spin-on.cfm#cross

These filters do not have a bypass...they filter all the oil and have exceptionally high flow rates. CM says the filter will last 10K under normal use.

Another alternative is to use a dual filter head with a conventional filter on one side and a Trasko bypass filter on the other...you want the T3/4-20S:
http://www.trasko-usa.com/

After the 1st change at 4-5K (cleans the motor out), you could achieve keeping both filters on for 8-10K...the key wll be the visual inspection of the Trasko. You can see the crap from your motor work it's way up the filter on removal. This allows you to adjust the next interval.

The benefit of going this route is your oil will be very clean (< 1 micron for particles)...a bypass filter removes all contaminates. You can run your oil until Blackstone says to change it...I've seen oil go 15-16K (a couple times more than that) before TBN was depleted. The change interval is going to depend on how much make-up oil you add over time that replinishes the additives.

Piratetip
11-18-2009, 08:00 PM
I finally put enough miles on my daily to post up a UOA.
Have a look.
http://i301.photobucket.com/albums/nn77/ntippet/ntippet.jpg

jdub
11-18-2009, 09:11 PM
10,500 miles!!! Don't you know that you cant run an oil that long!
Think about all the starving kids at Jiffy Lube ;)

LOL...those are excellent numbers. I agree with Blackstone, run it 12,500 next time. You gotta love GC :)

Piratetip
11-18-2009, 09:36 PM
Ah screw those oil change places. :)

I feel bad I tossed the oil, should have run it in the old lawn mower or something.

The oil was very dark when I drained it, goes to show you cant tell whats happening unless you get it tested.
The cost of this analysis is more than justified by the invaluable data.

Was averaging 38mpg on it too, has since dropped off some. I think winter blend petrol is being used now.